Before a judge or jury ever hears your story, Indiana law often asks a small group of health care professionals to review it first. That group is the medical review panel, which includes three health care providers and one attorney, and it issues a written opinion on whether a provider met the standard of care. The opinion does not decide your case, but it shapes how your claim moves forward, so understanding it early can bring real peace of mind.
At Wagner Reese, LLP, we help injured patients and their families work through this process as Indiana medical malpractice lawyers who understand how each stage unfolds. Below, we explain how the panel is formed, what it reviews, and what its opinion means for you.
How Indiana’s Medical Review Panel Works
In Indiana, a patient who believes a qualified health care provider caused harm usually cannot go straight to court. The claim starts when a proposed complaint is filed with the Indiana Department of Insurance. A panel is not created automatically, and the Indiana Department of Insurance explains that either side must request one no earlier than 20 days after the complaint is filed.
Each panel has one attorney and three health care providers. The attorney serves as chairperson and does not vote. The two sides usually agree on the chairperson, each side then selects one provider, and those two providers choose the third. Together, the providers weigh whether the care met the standard of care, which means the level of care a reasonably careful provider would give in a similar situation.
What Happens After the Panel Is Formed
Once the panel is in place, the case moves through a few clear stages. Here is how those stages work:
- Evidence submission: Both sides send written evidence to the panel, including medical charts, X-rays, lab tests, and depositions.
- Optional meeting: After the evidence is in, either side may ask the panel to meet and answer questions from both parties.
- Written opinion: The panel should deliver a signed opinion within 180 days of choosing its last member.
Those stages show why preparation matters, because the panel reviews written evidence only. A clear, well-organized submission helps the panel understand exactly what happened, whether your claim involves a failure to diagnose, surgical errors, or emergency room errors. We can gather the records and build that submission with you so your story comes through.
How the Panel’s Opinion Affects Your Claim
The opinion is an important part of your claim, but it is not the final word. Whether the panel agrees with you or not, you may still take your case to court afterward. A favorable opinion can support your position as the case moves forward, while an unfavorable one is something we can help you weigh carefully.
Timing matters too. The Indiana Department of Insurance states that filing a proposed complaint extends the statute of limitations until 90 days after you receive the panel’s opinion. That protection helps, but it works only when the complaint is filed correctly with the required fees. The side in whose favor the majority opinion is written also pays the panel’s fees, which the department says average about $4,000.
Why Legal Guidance Matters During the Panel Process
Because the panel reviews written evidence, strong medical records and a clear explanation of what went wrong carry real weight. A missed deadline or an incomplete submission can slow your claim or put it at risk. An attorney who knows the Indiana Medical Malpractice Act can help you avoid those problems.
We also keep you informed as the process unfolds. The process can take months, and waiting is hard when you are dealing with medical bills and recovery. We explain each step in plain language so you always know where your claim stands and what comes next.
Contact Wagner Reese, LLP About Your Medical Malpractice Claim
Indiana’s medical review panel is a required first step for many claims, and it affects how long your case takes, what evidence you present, and what options you have afterward. You do not have to learn the process alone. We can guide you through each stage, from filing the proposed complaint to presenting your evidence to the panel.
Wagner Reese was founded in 2000 by Jason Reese and Stephen Wagner, and Attorney Reese has been named among Indiana’s Top 25 Medical Malpractice Trial Lawyers by the Medical Malpractice Trial Lawyers Association. You can read about the outcomes we have achieved for clients on our case results page. When you are ready to talk about your situation, reach out to us through our contact form.