Our Team

Alexander Carlisle

Wagner Reese Logo
Alexander Carlisle Headshot

Mr. Carlisle focuses his practice on representing injured parties and their families in personal injury, civil rights, and wrongful death cases.

Prior to representing injured parties, Mr. Carlisle served for more than five years as a Deputy Attorney General for the State of Indiana, where he defended state agencies, officials, and employees in civil rights and employment disputes before state and federal courts. At the Attorney General’s Office, Mr. Carlisle successfully tried several cases to juries in federal court and frequently obtained favorable judgments on motions practice. He also served as the Assistant Section Chief of the Government Litigation section, where he helped oversee a dedicated group of attorneys and paralegals.

Before his tenure at the State, Mr. Carlisle worked as an associate attorney for a law firm in Indianapolis, where he gained experience across many areas of the law, including insurance defense, school and municipal matters, and environmental and utilities law. His prior work has given him an invaluable perspective into how insurers and the government value and defend cases brought by injured parties.

In all cases, Mr. Carlisle is a steadfast advocate who strives to obtain the best possible legal outcomes for his clients. He walks alongside them in their pursuit of justice, giving them a voice to tell their story. He understands the deep and direct impact his work has on his clients’ lives.

Alex is a lifelong Hoosier who grew up on the south side of Indianapolis. He obtained his undergraduate degree from Indiana University Bloomington and his law degree from the IU McKinney School of Law. Alex is a member of the Indiana Trial Lawyers Association and the Indianapolis Bar Association and has published articles in the Indiana Law Review. He is active in his Greenwood church plant and the Franklin community. He and his wife, Bronwen, are proud parents of two young boys.

Case Results

Wagner Reese Logo

Indiana’s Most Successful Personal Injury Case Results

These aren’t just numbers - they’re real families we’ve helped.

$22 Million

Wrongful Death

$17 Million

Catastrophic Injury

Gas explosion settlement for burn victims.

$14 Million

Sex Abuse Victim

$14 Million settlement for sex abuse victim.

$10 Million

Catastrophic Injury

Wagner Reese obtained a policy limits settlement for a toddler and mother who were badly burned in a natural gas flash fire resulting from And him properly maintained water heater in an apartment complex.

$9.3 Million

Product Liability

Attorneys Jason Reese and Jeff Gibson settled a $9.3M Product Liability claim.

$6.62 Million

Construction Accident

While working on a construction site for a commercial building, a worker suffered catastrophic injuries due to negligence by one of the subcontractors. A global settlement between parties sharing responsibility was reached for over $6.625M for the worker.

$6.5 Million

Wrongful Death

Wrongful death settlement for wife and mother of three children due to semi-truck negligence.

$5.5 Million

Vehicle Accident

A 19-year old was paralyzed in a car crash. Wagner Reese was able to recover the full insurance policy limits in just 5 months.

$5 Million

Construction Site

$5 Million recovered for construction site accident.

$4.57 Million

Truck Accident

Underinsured motorist claim against a truck driver’s employer. The truck driver was operating a truck and was transporting materials near Tampa, Florida when he witnessed a motor vehicle accident and stopped to render help to the accident victims. During the course of the rescue efforts, another vehicle came along and struck the vehicle and seriously […]

Media Features

13 Wthr
Abc 21
CBS4
Cnn
Current
Fox 59
Indystar
Reuters
Tn HLF
Wgn9 Logo
Wishtv
Yahoo News

Contact Information

Schedule with Alexander

Carmel Office

11939 N. Meridian St. Carmel, IN 46032

Get Directions