Our Team

Autumn L. Seib

Attorney

Wagner Reese Logo
Autumn L. Seib Headshot

Medical Malpractice Focus

Focused on representing patients and families harmed by medical negligence

Award-Winning Attorney

Recognized by Indiana Super Lawyers Rising Star (2024–2026), Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch (2025–2026), and The National Trial Lawyers Top 40 Under 40 Civil Plaintiff Litigation (2023–2025)

Academic Excellence

Valedictorian who earned both bachelor’s and master’s degrees with perfect GPAs and received a scholarship to Indiana University Maurer School of Law, bringing that same discipline to her practice

Legal Career

Autumn is a medical malpractice attorney who represents patients and families when medical errors cause life-altering harm. She brings a detail-oriented approach to case preparation and a focused, disciplined style of advocacy. She understands that behind every case is a person whose life has been profoundly affected, and she approaches each matter with care—working to understand what happened, identify the key issues, and advocate so her clients’ voices are heard. She is committed to giving every case the thorough preparation and focused attention it deserves.

Autumn approaches Indiana’s medical malpractice system with precision and strategy. Because Indiana law requires many claims to first be submitted to a Medical Review Panel—a stage that often shapes the trajectory of a case—she uses that process to develop and present the case early. Through detailed written submissions, she presents the evidence clearly and works to build the strongest possible case for the Medical Review Panel.

She is experienced in depositions, hearings, and courtroom proceedings, where she works to pursue accountability and ensure that important details are fully examined. Her approach combines thorough preparation, command of the facts, and strategic advocacy in response to defense positions.

Autumn’s perspective is informed by her prior experience representing healthcare providers and insurance companies. She understands how defense teams evaluate claims and works to anticipate and respond to those strategies.

Legal Practice & Personal Life

Her work has been recognized by Indiana Super Lawyers Rising Star (2024–2026), Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch (2025–2026), and National Trial Lawyers Top 40 Under 40 Civil Plaintiff Litigation (2023–2025). She is admitted to practice in Indiana and Michigan, as well as in Indiana’s federal courts.

Originally from Lapeer, Michigan, Autumn graduated as valedictorian of her high school class before earning both her bachelor’s and master’s degrees—with perfect GPAs—in four years from Central Michigan University. She went on to attend Indiana University Maurer School of Law on scholarship, where she earned her Juris Doctor.

Outside of her practice, Autumn lives on the north side of Indianapolis and enjoys running the Monon Trail, staying active outdoors, watching sports, cooking, and spending time with family, friends, and her Cavalier King Charles Spaniel, Chester.

Autumn L. Seib’s Practice Areas

Case Results

Wagner Reese Logo

Indiana’s Most Successful Personal Injury Case Results

These aren’t just numbers - they’re real families we’ve helped.

$22 Million

Wrongful Death

$14 Million

Sex Abuse Victim

$14 Million settlement for sex abuse victim.

$10 Million

Catastrophic Injury

Wagner Reese obtained a policy limits settlement for a toddler and mother who were badly burned in a natural gas flash fire resulting from And him properly maintained water heater in an apartment complex.

$9.3 Million

Product Liability

Attorneys Jason Reese and Jeff Gibson settled a $9.3M Product Liability claim.

$6.62 Million

Construction Accident

While working on a construction site for a commercial building, a worker suffered catastrophic injuries due to negligence by one of the subcontractors. A global settlement between parties sharing responsibility was reached for over $6.625M for the worker.

$5.5 Million

Vehicle Accident

A 19-year old was paralyzed in a car crash. Wagner Reese was able to recover the full insurance policy limits in just 5 months.

$5 Million

Construction Site

$5 Million recovered for construction site accident.

$4.57 Million

Truck Accident

Underinsured motorist claim against a truck driver’s employer. The truck driver was operating a truck and was transporting materials near Tampa, Florida when he witnessed a motor vehicle accident and stopped to render help to the accident victims. During the course of the rescue efforts, another vehicle came along and struck the vehicle and seriously […]

$4 Million

Vehicle Accident

Settlement for primary bread-winner father and husband killed as a result of negligence of a semi-tractor trailer operator who filed to yield the right-of-way.

$3.7 Million

Catastrophic Injury

A young man suffered paralysis to his lower body when a bucket of parts was negligently dropped on his head. The defendant argued that the client was a co-worker of the employee that dropped the bucket on him, thus limiting our client to worker’s compensation benefits. Wagner Reese argued that they were not co-employees because […]

What Clients Have to Say About Autumn L. Seib

Media Features

13 Wthr
Abc 21
CBS4
Cnn
Current
Fox 59
Indystar
Reuters
Tn HLF
Wgn9 Logo
Wishtv
Yahoo News

Contact Information

Schedule with Autumn

Carmel Office

11939 N. Meridian St. Carmel, IN 46032

Get Directions