If you share some blame for a crash, you may worry your claim is over before it starts. In Indiana, that is often not the case. Under the state’s modified comparative fault rule, you may still recover compensation as long as you are not more than 50 percent responsible for the accident, although your payment is reduced by your share of the blame.

Fault is often the most disputed part of a crash claim, and the percentages assigned to each driver can change what you receive. Wagner Reese LLP helps injured drivers across Indiana, and our Carmel car accident lawyers work to shield your claim from unfair fault arguments. Here is how the rule works and what you can do to keep your percentage low.

How Indiana Divides Fault After a Crash

Indiana law treats fault as a percentage. A jury looks at what each person did and assigns a share of the blame to you, to each defendant, and sometimes to a person who is not part of the lawsuit. Those shares decide both whether you can recover and how much you may receive.

The rules come from the Indiana Comparative Fault Act, which covers most claims for injury or property damage caused by fault. Our guide to comparative negligence covers the basics, and the main points are simple. Insurance adjusters may use the same percentage approach when they negotiate a settlement.

What the 50 Percent Bar Means for Your Payment

The rule has two parts. First, any fault assigned to you lowers your compensation by the same percentage. For example, say a jury finds your damages total $100,000 and decides you were 20 percent at fault. Your award may be reduced by $20,000, which leaves $80,000.

Second, you are barred from recovery if your fault is greater than the combined fault of everyone else involved. In practical terms, 50 percent or less means you may still recover, while 51 percent means you may receive nothing. That one percentage point can decide the entire case, so every detail of the crash matters.

How Insurance Companies Try to Raise Your Share of Fault

Because the 50 percent line matters so much, an insurance company may look for reasons to increase your percentage. Adjusters may point to several things after a crash, including:

  • speeding or following too closely before the collision
  • looking at a phone or another distraction
  • failing to yield at an intersection or while turning
  • braking suddenly or changing lanes without warning

Each of these claims can be challenged with evidence such as photos, witness statements, vehicle damage patterns, and traffic camera video. Disputes over left-turn accidents are a good example, because both drivers often claim the other one had the right of way.

Nonparties, Liens, and Government Claims

A defendant may also argue someone who is not in the lawsuit caused part of the crash. A jury can assign that nonparty a share of the fault, and the amount you may recover from the defendant is reduced by that share. This is one more reason to identify every driver and vehicle involved as early as possible.

Liens follow the same math. If a health insurer or another payer has a claim on your settlement, Indiana law reduces that claim in the same proportion as your recovery. Claims against a city, county, or state agency follow separate rules under the Indiana Tort Claims Act, so it helps to talk with a lawyer early.

Steps That Help Protect Your Percentage

Strong evidence is the best way to protect your percentage of fault. Take photos of the scene and vehicles, collect witness contact information, and seek medical care right away. Our guide on what to do after a car accident in Indiana walks through each step.

Be careful with your words, too. When an insurance company calls you after a crash, a casual comment about what you did may be used to raise your share of the blame. Indiana also limits how long you have to file, so review the time limit for filing a car accident claim soon.

Contact Wagner Reese LLP About Your Car Accident Claim

Shared fault does not have to end your claim. Our attorneys bring more than 150 years of combined legal experience, and our firm holds a Tier 1 Best Law Firms ranking for personal injury litigation. Founding partner Stephen Wagner was named the Indiana Trial Lawyer of the Year in 2006, and we have recovered more than $300 million for injured clients.

We work to gather the evidence needed to show how your crash happened so the fault assigned to you is fair. If you were hurt in a crash, even one you may share some blame for, contact us for a free consultation through our contact form.

Back to Blog